Upsy Daisy

The ColourPop Upsy Daisy Crème Gel Liner Kit contains five twist-up pencil eyeliners in a variety of new and discontinued hues. This set was better than others I’ve tried from ColourPop since the bulk of the products were creamy enough to apply without getting uneven or cracking, which have been concerns in the past.

ColourPop Extra Frosting Crème Gel Liner

Extra Frosting

Extra Frosting is a light yellow with warm undertones and a matte sheen. It offered semi-opaque color coverage and a somewhat waxy texture that seemed to push product around more than optimal, resulting in uneven application. It was really visible at the water line, therefore it didn’t work well for brightening on me. It wore nicely for seven hours before dramatically thinning.

ColourPop On Point Crème Gel Liner

On Point

On Point is a medium-dark orange-coral with warm undertones and a glossy shine. The texture was softly creamy, so it went smoothly across my lash line without dragging, but it didn’t feel too moist. In one pass, it achieved mostly opaque color coverage. It lasted around eight hours before dramatically thinning.

ColourPop Idyllic Crème Gel Liner

Idyllic

Idyllic is a dark olive green with a matte sheen and warmer undertones. It had a semi-opaque color payoff and a softly creamy texture that was easy to work with, while it didn’t layer evenly–as a thin line, it wasn’t visible in person. It remained on for eight hours before thinning somewhat.

ColourPop Captivating Crème Gel Liner

Captivating

Captivating is a golden bronze with a beautiful, pearly shine that is light-medium in tone. It provided opaque pigmentation in a single coat and a smooth, creamy consistency that flowed smoothly across my lash line. It wore nicely for eight hours before dramatically thinning.

ColourPop Sunnyvale Crème Gel Liner

Sunnyvale

Sunnyvale is a rich reddish-brown with warm undertones and a matte texture. The texture was smooth and gently creamy, but it hardened quickly. It had opaque pigmentation that lasted for eight hours before dramatically diminishing.