Trump White House shelves ‘adversarial’ review of climate science

The proposed White House panel that would conduct an “adversarial” review of climate science is dead for now, as President Donald Trump grapples with negative perceptions of his environmental record at the outset of his reelection campaign.

The months-long push from within the National Security Council to review established science on climate change divided White House advisers and generated sharp opposition from researchers across the country. The effort, led by a physicist overseeing technology issues at the NSC, William Happer, stalled indefinitely amid internal disagreements within the White House, according to two sources.

“It’s been totally stymied by the forces of darkness within the administration, but also by the looming election campaign,” said Myron Ebell, a senior fellow at the conservative Competitive Enterprise Institute in Washington, D.C., who led the Environmental Protection Agency transition team under Trump.

Happer has consulted conservative groups that attack climate science in an attempt to recruit members for the proposed panel. He’s spoken with policy analysts at the Competitive Enterprise Institute, the Heartland Institute in Arlington Heights, Illinois, and the CO2 Coalition, a group Happer founded and that claims that the world would be better off with higher levels of carbon dioxide emissions. The theories promoted by those groups are rejected by NASA, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration and the world’s top science academies.

Happer initially wanted Trump to issue an executive order to create the “Presidential Committee on Climate Security.” He wanted the panel to review assertions within the National Climate Assessment related to risks from climate change on national security. Happer briefed Trump on climate science at least twice (Climatewire, June 24).

The idea to create the panel has caused strife within the White House. Among its critics are deputy chief of staff Chris Liddell; Kevin Hassett, the outgoing chairman of the Council of Economic Advisers; Larry Kudlow, director of the National Economic Council; and Kelvin Droegemeier, the president’s science adviser. Those supporting the plan include Trump’s son-in-law and senior adviser Jared Kushner and Brooke Rollins, assistant to Trump in the Office of American Innovation.

An official at NSC disputed the characterization that the panel was dead, even while confirming that it had been indefinitely delayed. The plan has suffered several downgrades over the months. It was initially proposed as a rapid response team of climate science critics who would challenge government publications on human-caused warming. Recent discussions have centered on the idea of forcing government climate scientists to participate in a debate with critics of their work who deny that humans are causing widespread changes on Earth (Climatewire, June 6). Most recently, the plan was diminished to creating dueling white papers that would elevate climate denialism to the level of consensus science.

Those in talks to participate as critics of mainstream science include John Christy of the University of Alabama, Huntsville, and Judith Curry, former head of the School of Earth and Atmospheric Sciences at Georgia Tech in Atlanta, Georgia. A potential leader of the exercise was Paul Robinson, a former Department of Energy official who oversaw talks about nuclear weapons tests with the Soviet Union, but who is not trained in climate science.

Trump supporters who want the administration to be more aggressive in its rejection of climate science were frustrated that the climate review panel had been sidelined. Ebell of the Competitive Enterprise Institute sees it as a sign that the Trump campaign is sensitive to Democratic attacks on climate change.

“The reelect campaign has been completely taken over by the usual cast of Republican establishment consultants who are primarily concerned with making very large amounts of money on the campaign,” Ebell said.

Reprinted from Climatewire with permission from E&E News. Copyright 2019. E&E provides essential news for energy and environment professionals at www.eenews.net

Source: Sciencemag.org

Powered by NewsAPI.org

Keywords:

Executive Office of the President • Adversarial review • Climatology • Executive Office of the President • Adversarial review • Climatology • Donald Trump • United States National Security Council • Climate change • White House • Physicist • Technology • United States National Security Council • William Happer • Executive Office of the President • Presidency of George W. Bush • Myron Ebell • Conservatism in the United States • Competitive Enterprise Institute • Washington, D.C. • United States Environmental Protection Agency • Presidential transition of Donald Trump • Donald Trump • William Happer • Conservatism in the United States • Climatology • Competitive Enterprise Institute • The Heartland Institute • Arlington Heights, Illinois • Carbon dioxide • William Happer • Carbon dioxide • NASA • National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration • William Happer • Donald Trump • Executive order (United States) • President of the United States • Climate security • National Climate Assessment • Climate change • National security • Donald Trump • Climatology • Environment & Energy Publishing • White House • White House Chief of Staff • Chris Liddell • Kevin Hassett • Chair of the Federal Reserve • Council of Economic Advisers • Lawrence Kudlow • National Economic Council (United States) • President of the United States • Donald Trump • Jared Kushner • Brooke Rollins • Donald Trump • Office of American Innovation • United States National Security Council • Rapid response team (medicine) • Climatology • Government • Human • Global warming • Idea • Government • Scientific opinion on climate change • Human • Earth • Environment & Energy Publishing • Climate change • Denialism • Scientific consensus • John Christy • University of Alabama in Huntsville • Judith Curry • Earth • Atmospheric sciences • Georgia Institute of Technology • Atlanta • Paul Robinson (figure skater) • United States Department of Energy • Nuclear weapons testing • Soviet Union • Climatology • Presidency of George W. Bush • Climatology • Myron Ebell • Competitive Enterprise Institute • Donald Trump presidential campaign, 2016 • Democratic Party (United States) • Climate change • Republican Party (United States) • Environment & Energy Publishing • E! • Copyright •