Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Understands Democracy Better Than Republicans Do - The New York Times

In more modern terms, the founders feared “direct democracy” and accounted for its dangers with a system of “representative democracy.” Yes, this “republic” had counter-majoritarian aspects, like equal representation of states in the Senate, the presidential veto and the Supreme Court. But it was not designed for minority rule.

Virtually everything was geared toward producing representative majorities that could govern on behalf of the country — to diminish “faction” in favor of consensus. And in the case of the Electoral College, the point wasn’t to stymie majorities but to provide a way to find a competent and popular chief executive in a large nation of parochial states.

It’s worth asking where this quip — “we’re a republic, not a democracy” — even came from. Nicole Hemmer, a historian of American politics and the author of “Messengers of the Right: Conservative Media and the Transformation of American Politics,” traces it to the 1930s and 40s. “When Franklin Roosevelt made defending democracy a core component of his argument for preparing for, and then intervening in, the war in Europe, opponents of U.S. intervention began to push back by arguing that the U.S. was not, in fact, a democracy,” she wrote in an email.

One Roosevelt opponent, for example — Boake Carter, a newspaper columnist who supported the America First Committee (which opposed American entry into World War II) — wrote a column in October 1940 called “A Republic Not a Democracy,” in which he strongly rebuked the president for using the word “democracy” to describe the country. “The United States was never a democracy, isn’t a democracy, and I hope it will never be a democracy,” Carter wrote.

The term went from conservative complaint to right-wing slogan in the 1960s, when Robert Welch, the founder of the John Birch Society, used it in a September 1961 speech, “Republics and Democracies.” In a democracy, Welch protested, “there is a centralization of governmental power in a simple majority. And that, visibly, is the system of government which the enemies of our republic are seeking to impose on us today.”

“This is a Republic, not a Democracy,” Welch said in conclusion, “Let’s keep it that way!”

These origins are important. If there’s substance behind “We’re a republic, not a democracy,” it’s not as a description of American government. There’s really no difference, in the present, between a “republic” and a “democracy”: Both connote systems of representation in which sovereignty and authority derive from the public at large.

Source: The New York Times

Powered by NewsAPI.org

Keywords:

Alexandria • Hernán Cortés • Republicanism • The New York Times • Modern history • Direct democracy • Representative democracy • Republic • Majoritarianism • Representation (politics) • State (polity) • United States Senate • Veto • Supreme Court of the United States • Dominant minority • Representative democracy • Majority • Nation state • Separatism • Consensus decision-making • Case law • Electoral College (United States) • Majority • Executive (government) • Republic • Democracy • Historian • Politics of the United States • Right-wing politics • Conservatism • Politics of the United States • Franklin D. Roosevelt • Democracy • Democracy • Email • Boake Carter • America First Committee • World War II • Republic • Democracy • President of the United States • Democracy • United States • Democracy • Democracy • Democracy • Jimmy Carter • Conservatism • Right-wing politics • Counterculture of the 1960s • Robert W. Welch Jr. • John Birch Society • Freedom of speech • Republic • Democracy • Democracy • Centralisation • Government • Power (social and political) • Majority • Forms of government • Republic • Republic • Democracy • Let's Keep It That Way • Republic • Democracy • Difference (philosophy) • Republic • Democracy • Connotation • Representative democracy • Sovereignty • Authority •